Monthly payment processing cost calculator
Small businesses often need a monthly or annual fee picture—not just the cost on a single $100 charge. Enter your card sales volume, how many transactions you run (or your average ticket), and any fixed monthly subscription. This tool projects processing fees using the same per-charge math as CardFeeCalc’s processor calculators (including P2P business and POS pages), then ranks processors by total monthly cost.
Already have a statement? Audit your real effective rate. Need one charge? Use the Stripe vs Square vs PayPal comparison. Marketplace sellers: try monthly volume mode on Etsy, eBay, and other marketplace calculators. Niche comparisons: coffee shop & restaurant (Square vs Toast) and e-commerce store (Shopify Payments vs Stripe).
How the fee is calculated
Per transaction: fee = round(ticket × percent + fixed fee) (same as each processor page). Monthly: sum fees across your transaction count at the average ticket implied by volume ÷ transactions. Fixed per-transaction fees matter more when average tickets are small—monthly volume mode captures that.
Source: Stripe; Square (online); Square (in-person); PayPal; Venmo Business; Cash App Business; Clover; Toast; Helcim (IC+ est.); QuickBooks Payments. Toast uses an illustrative example rate; Helcim uses editable illustrative interchange plus published margin tiers.
Uses the same published US rates as Stripe, Square, and PayPal calculators, including Venmo Business, Cash App Business, Clover, Toast, Helcim (IC+ estimate), and Square in-person. Square mix is optional for the online Square row; open each processor page for plan-specific pricing.
Average ticket = volume ÷ transactions (used for per-transaction fixed fees).
Plan or POS subscription added to monthly and annual totals—not deducted from sales volume.
Square sales mix (% of volume)
Mix should total 100% (currently 100%). Values are normalized if they do not sum exactly.
Monthly total cost (ranked lowest first)
- #1 Venmo Business$210.00/mo
Processing $210.00
- #2 Helcim (IC+ est.)$258.00/mo
Processing $258.00
- #3 Clover$280.00/mo
Processing $280.00
- #3 Toast$280.00/mo
Processing $280.00
- #5 Square (in-person)$290.00/mo
Processing $290.00
- #5 Cash App Business$290.00/mo
Processing $290.00
- #7 QuickBooks Payments$300.00/mo
Processing $300.00
- #8 Stripe$350.00/mo
Processing $350.00
- #9 Square (online)$390.00/mo
Processing $390.00
- #10 PayPal$448.00/mo
Processing $448.00
| Rank | Processor | Monthly cost | Annual cost | Effective rate | Net revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Venmo Business | $210.00 | $2,520.00 | 2.10% | $9,790.00 |
| 2 | Helcim (IC+ est.) | $258.00 | $3,096.00 | 2.58% | $9,742.00 |
| 3 | Clover | $280.00 | $3,360.00 | 2.80% | $9,720.00 |
| 3 | Toast | $280.00 | $3,360.00 | 2.80% | $9,720.00 |
| 5 | Square (in-person) | $290.00 | $3,480.00 | 2.90% | $9,710.00 |
| 5 | Cash App Business | $290.00 | $3,480.00 | 2.90% | $9,710.00 |
| 7 | QuickBooks Payments | $300.00 | $3,600.00 | 3.00% | $9,700.00 |
| 8 | Stripe | $350.00 | $4,200.00 | 3.50% | $9,650.00 |
| 9 | Square (online) | $390.00 | $4,680.00 | 3.90% | $9,610.00 |
| 10 | PayPal | $448.00 | $5,376.00 | 4.48% | $9,552.00 |
FAQ
- How is monthly processing cost calculated on CardFeeCalc?
- We apply the same published percent-plus-fixed rate as each processor’s per-transaction calculator to your average ticket (monthly volume ÷ transaction count), multiply by the number of transactions, and round to cents. Optional monthly subscription fees are added to monthly and annual totals but are not taken from sales volume.
- Why does transaction count matter if I already entered monthly volume?
- Processors charge a fixed fee on every successful card charge—not just a percent of volume. Two businesses with $10,000 in sales pay very different totals if one runs 50 large tickets vs. 500 small ones. Entering transaction count (or average ticket) models those fixed fees.
- Which rates does this monthly calculator use?
- This page compares all 10 processors in the monthly table: Stripe online, Square online (optional in-person/keyed mix on the Square row only), Square in-person, PayPal Checkout, Venmo Business, Cash App Business, Clover, Toast (illustrative example rate), and Helcim IC+ with illustrative interchange—using published or labeled rates from each processor’s official sources. See each processor’s calculator for full rate options.
- Can I share my monthly volume scenario?
- Yes. Monthly mode syncs volume, transactions, subscription, and Square mix to the URL query string (mode=monthly, vol, txns or avg, sub, mix_*). Copy the address bar to share or bookmark.
- Does net revenue include subscription fees?
- Net revenue on this page is card sales volume minus processing fees only—it does not subtract optional subscription inputs. Monthly total cost includes both processing and subscription when you enter a subscription.
Is this figure right?
What's missing? Suggest a calculator or feature